MUbase

Solutions for your tasks

HR | base8 min readUpdated:

Employee appraisal, process and goals for SMEs

Prepare and conduct an employee appraisal in an SME. Self-assessment, weighted SMART goals, bonuses, records and data protection, with an example.

KMU | base editorial team

By emailLinkedIn
Fountain pen on a blank white sheet of writing paper

A good employee appraisal looks back, clarifies expectations and records what should be achieved in the coming year. In many SMEs it still takes place irregularly because a template, time or a clear process is missing. This guide shows how to prepare and conduct an appraisal, formulate measurable goals and assign weights, address goals linked to a bonus, and retain the record in line with data protection requirements. A worked example shows weighted goal achievement.

Are employee appraisals compulsory?

Swiss law does not prescribe an annual employee appraisal. There are nevertheless good reasons for one. Employers must respect and protect employees’ personality rights (Art. 328 CO) and issue an employment reference on request at any time (Art. 330a CO). A reference must be truthful and benevolent. Documented appraisals help ground it in facts (SECO, employment reference FAQ). Explaining salary increases and promotions through established criteria also helps prevent allegations of unequal treatment. The Gender Equality Act expressly prohibits discrimination on grounds of sex in remuneration and promotion (Art. 3 GlG).

An annual appraisal, with a short interim discussion after six months if needed, has proved effective. New employees also have a probation review. See the guide to probation in the employment contract.

Preparation, self-assessment and criteria

A conversation works when both sides arrive prepared. Establish and communicate the criteria beforehand, for example in the following areas.

  • Professional competence. Quality of work and independence.
  • Working methods. Reliability, organisation and handling deadlines.
  • Conduct. Collaboration, customer contact and response to criticism.
  • Leadership, for managers. Setting goals, giving feedback and developing the team.
  • Goals. Achievement of the goals agreed at the last appraisal.

Ask employees to complete a self-assessment with a rating for each criterion and a short explanation. The line manager assesses the same criteria. Differences between the two assessments are the most valuable part of the conversation because they reveal misunderstandings.

Allow at least an hour in a quiet room without interruptions. Announce the appointment two to three weeks in advance.

The conversation in five parts

  1. Opening. Clarify the purpose and process, allowing the employee to speak first.
  2. Looking back. Discuss what went well and what did not, reviewing each of last year’s goals individually.
  3. Assessment. Compare criteria, discuss differences and give concrete examples.
  4. Looking ahead. Agree new goals, discuss further training and development, and hear the employee’s wishes.
  5. Closing. Summarise the results and record next steps and deadlines.

Where possible, separate the development conversation from the pay review. Someone negotiating salary in the same meeting will rarely speak openly about weaknesses.

Setting measurable goals and weights

Goals work only when it is clear at the end whether they have been met. The familiar SMART rule helps make them specific, measurable, accepted, realistic and time-bound. “Look after customers better” could become “Send quotations within three working days of the site visit, measured across all quotations from January to December”.

Three to five goals are sufficient. Give each a weight, with the total adding up to 100 per cent. At year-end, assess achievement for each goal as a percentage and calculate the weighted overall result. Multiply each weight by the corresponding achievement rate and add the results together. An important goal then counts more than a secondary one.

Record what happens if circumstances change, for example during a long illness or after new duties are assigned. A goal that no longer fits is adjusted during the interim discussion instead of being silently dropped.

Goals and bonuses, salary or gratification?

If a bonus depends on goal achievement, careful wording matters. The CO distinguishes salary (Art. 322 CO) from gratification, a special payment to which an entitlement exists only if agreed (Art. 322d CO). Where a bonus is determined or determinable by fixed criteria, such as a fixed amount for full goal achievement, there are strong indications that it forms part of salary to which the employee is entitled. Where the employer retains discretion, the payment is more likely to be gratification. Drawing the distinction in an individual case is demanding. Put the rules in writing and have bonus regulations reviewed professionally when in doubt.

Record, confirmation and data protection

Record the results in a short written record covering assessments, agreed goals with weights and deadlines, development measures and comments from both sides. Both sides confirm the record. Differing opinions belong in its comments as well.

The rules on data protection in employment apply to the record. Employers may process only data concerning suitability for the employment relationship or necessary to perform the employment contract (Art. 328b CO). Employees may request information about their data, including access to appraisals (Art. 25 DSG). Personal data must be destroyed or anonymised once it is no longer needed for its purpose (Art. 6 para. 4 DSG). The Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner describes which data may be processed at each stage of employment. File the records in the personnel dossier, accessible only to HR and the line manager, and establish when they will be deleted. The guide to personnel data protection provides further information.

Practical example, Schreinerei Graf AG

Schreinerei Graf AG is a fictitious business with 18 employees. In January 2026, project manager Jonas Meier agrees three goals with the owner. In December 2026, they assess achievement together.

GoalWeightAchievementWeighted result
Send quotations within three working days50%100%50%
Complete post-costing for all orders above CHF 10’00030%80%24%
Prepare the second-year apprentice for the partial examination20%50%10%
Overall achievement100%84%
Goal
Send quotations within three working days
Weight
50%
Achievement
100%
Weighted result
50%
Goal
Complete post-costing for all orders above CHF 10’000
Weight
30%
Achievement
80%
Weighted result
24%
Goal
Prepare the second-year apprentice for the partial examination
Weight
20%
Achievement
50%
Weighted result
10%
Goal
Overall achievement
Weight
100%
Achievement
Weighted result
84%

The third goal scored lower because the apprentice was absent for two months following an accident. The owner and project manager record this and carry an adjusted goal into 2027. Since the employment contract provides for no bonus, the overall result has no direct salary consequence. The owner uses it as a basis for the pay review in February. Both confirm the record, which is stored in the personnel dossier.

Checklist

  • Criteria established and communicated for employees and managers
  • Appointment agreed two to three weeks ahead, at least an hour reserved
  • Self-assessment and line manager assessment prepared
  • Previous year’s goals assessed individually
  • Three to five new SMART goals, with weights totalling 100%
  • Bonus rule, if applicable, clear and in writing
  • Record confirmed by both sides, with comments included
  • Filed in the personnel dossier with access rights and a deletion period
  • Interim discussion entered in the calendar

How KMU | base helps

HR | base manages appraisals and goals directly in the personnel file.

Templates. Appraisal templates let you set weighted criteria for each section, professional competence, working methods, conduct, leadership and goals. They can be separate for managers and employees and, if desired, specific to a role or department.

Plan review rounds. Recurring appraisal cycles let you schedule annual, half-yearly or one-off rounds for everyone, one company or a department. The reference date, lead time and deadlines can be configured. The appropriate template is selected automatically. For each round, you can see where self-assessments or manager assessments are missing and where the conversation is still pending.

Self-assessment. Employees complete their assessment on the Web or in the app, giving each criterion a rating from 1 to 5 and an explanation.

Conversation and goals. The appraisal record holds goals with deadlines, weights and achievement rates. HR | base calculates weighted overall achievement.

Confirmation. The employee and line manager confirm the conversation digitally, after which it is locked. HR can reset confirmation. The probation review follows the same process.

Data protection. Roles determine who sees appraisals. The access log records who accessed them and when.

Explore the demo or open a trial account. The guide to writing an employment reference provides further information.

Frequently asked questions

Is an annual employee appraisal compulsory?

Swiss law does not prescribe an annual employee appraisal.

How is weighted goal achievement calculated?

Multiply the weight of each goal by its achievement rate, then add the results together.

Who confirms the conversation in HR | base?

The employee and line manager confirm it digitally, after which it is locked. HR can reset confirmation.

Sources

  • Code of Obligations (OR, SR 220), Art. 322, 322d, 328, 328b, 330a, version of 1 October 2026: fedlex.admin.ch, accessed on 14.11.2026.
  • Federal Act on Data Protection (DSG, SR 235.1), Art. 6 Abs. 4 und Art. 25: fedlex.admin.ch, accessed on 14.11.2026.
  • Gender Equality Act (GlG, SR 151.1), Art. 3: fedlex.admin.ch, accessed on 14.11.2026.
  • FDPIC, different stages of the employment relationship: edoeb.admin.ch, accessed on 14.11.2026.
  • SECO, employment reference FAQ: seco.admin.ch, accessed on 14.11.2026.

This guide does not replace legal advice. Information current as of 14 November 2026.

From employee review to employment reference

See how reviews, goals, qualifications and employment references work together.

Back to top

Collaboration ×

The next step starts with a conversation.

What does your business need?